The European Commission has opened an in-depth investigation into
whether Hungary's advertisement tax introduced in June 2014 complies
with EU state aid rules. In particular, the Commission has concerns that
the progressive tax rates, ranging from 0 to 50%, could selectively
favour certain companies and give them an unfair competitive advantage.
The Commission has therefore also taken a separate decision prohibiting
Hungary from applying progressive rates until the Commission has
finished its assessment (a so-called "suspension injunction"). The
opening of an in-depth investigation gives interested third parties the
opportunity to comment. It does not prejudge the outcome of the
investigation.
Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: "It
is very important that we ensure a level playing field on media markets
throughout Europe. Many media today rely on advertisement income to
finance their operations. I welcome the signals from the Hungarian
government that they intend to make changes to the advertisement tax.
Our state aid investigation will look in detail both at how the
advertisement tax applies currently as well as how it is amended, to
make sure there is no unfair discrimination against certain media
companies."
Under Hungary's Advertisement Tax Act, companies
are taxed at a rate depending on their advertisement turnover and
companies with a higher advertisement turnover are subject to a
significantly higher tax rate. At this stage, the Commission considers
that this progressivity of the tax rates, ranging from 0% to 50%,
selectively favours certain media companies, in breach of EU state aid
rules...
Due to the progressive rates, companies with a low advertisement
turnover are liable to pay substantially less advertisement tax, even in
proportion to their advertisement turnover, than companies with a
higher advertisement turnover. A progressive tax based on turnover
places larger players at a disadvantage, unlike a progressive tax based
on profits, which can be justified by the higher burden-bearing capacity
of very profitable companies. At this stage, the Hungarian authorities
have not presented any objective reason that would justify this.
The
Commission also has doubts if the provisions in the Act, which allow
the deduction of previous losses from the taxable advertisement
turnover, are in line with state aid rules. These rules seem to be
inconsistent with the overall objective of the tax and their narrow
application only to companies that were not profit-making in 2013
appears to grant a selective advantage to these companies.
The
Commission's investigation does not call into question Hungary's right
to levy an advertisement tax or to determine the appropriate level of
taxation. However, the Commission has to verify that such a tax does not
selectively favour certain companies over their competitors. Hungary
and interested third parties can now submit their comments to the
Commission.
Following the investigation the Commission will decide
whether or not the advertisement tax gives rise to state aid to certain
companies and if there is aid, whether it complies with EU rules.
Background
Hungary
adopted the Advertisement Tax Act on 11 June 2014, with further
amendments on 4 July and 18 November 2014. The Act creates a new special
tax on advertisements published in the media in Hungary and applies to
all media companies.
The tax for each company is based on the
turnover derived from advertisement activities, without deduction of any
costs. The tax is therefore not based on the profits generated from
these activities. The tax base of affiliated companies is aggregated.
The tax rate is progressive: companies with small or medium-sized
advertisement turnover are either fully exempted or taxed at 1 %,
whereas companies with high advertisement turnover are taxed at a
progressive rate between 10% and 50%. For the tax year 2014, a
transitional measure allows companies to deduct from the 2014 tax base
50% of the losses carried forward from previous years under corporate or
personal income tax law. However, this possibility is limited to
companies that were not profit-making in 2013.
In parallel, the
Commission is also assessing the compatibility of the tax with other
aspects of EU law, notably with the freedom of establishment as
guaranteed by Article 49 TFEU in relation to whether the regime
primarily affects Hungarian companies linked to companies with
registered offices in other Member States. The Commission is currently
in contact with the Hungarian authorities to establish all relevant
facts.
The non-confidential version of the decision will be made available under the case number SA.39235 in the State Aid Register on the Commission's competition
website once any confidentiality issues have been resolved. New
publications of state aid decisions on the internet and in the Official
Journal are listed in the State Aid Weekly e-News.
